Rochester Dog Bite Lawyer

National Top 100 Trial Lawyers badge featuring Lady Justice silhouette with blue and gold circular design and legal award textA dog attack can leave injuries that extend well beyond the initial wound. Victims may need emergency treatment, surgery, follow-up care, or treatment for scarring and other lasting effects. At the same time, they may have questions about the dog’s history, whether the owner could have prevented the attack, and who will be responsible for the costs that follow.

New York law gives people injured by dogs more than one way to establish liability. Depending on what happened, a claim may focus on the dog’s prior behavior and what its owner knew, the owner’s failure to use reasonable care, or both.

Finkelstein & Partners represents people injured in dog attacks throughout New York. Our Rochester personal injury lawyers can investigate what happened, determine which legal theories may apply, and pursue compensation from those responsible. Our Rochester office is located at 104A Metro Park #8, and we offer free consultations to people who want to understand their options after a serious injury.

You can reach out to us by calling 585-639-3534 .

When Can You Bring a Dog Bite Claim in New York?

A dog owner may be legally responsible for an attack under two different theories: strict liability and negligence.

Under strict liability, the issue is whether the dog had a history or tendency that put people at risk and whether the owner knew or should have known about it. A previous bite can be important evidence, but it is not the only way to establish dangerous tendencies. Prior growling, snapping, lunging, attacks on other animals, or other aggressive behavior may also matter.

A negligence claim focuses instead on the owner’s conduct. A person injured by a dog may be able to show that the owner failed to use reasonable care under the circumstances and that this failure led to the injury. For example, the facts may involve inadequate restraint, an unsecured enclosure, or a failure to control the dog around other people.

A victim may pursue either theory or both when the evidence supports them.

What Evidence Can Strengthen a Rochester Dog Bite Case?

Dog bite cases often depend on information that the injured person would have no reason to know before the attack. The dog may have behaved aggressively toward neighbors, delivery workers, visitors, or other animals without that information ever reaching the victim.

Evidence that may help establish what happened and who was responsible can include:

  • Animal control and health department records.
  • Reports of previous bites or attacks.
  • Statements from neighbors, witnesses, postal workers, or others familiar with the dog.
  • Prior complaints about growling, lunging, snapping, or threatening behavior.
  • Veterinary or training records that document behavioral concerns.
  • Photographs or video of the dog, property, fence, leash, or other restraints.
  • Security camera, doorbell camera, or cellphone footage.
  • Text messages, emails, or social media posts concerning the dog’s behavior.
  • Evidence showing how the owner handled or restrained the dog before the attack.
  • Medical records documenting the injuries and treatment that followed.

The evidence needed will depend on the legal basis for the claim. If strict liability applies, the dog’s history and the owner’s knowledge may be central. In a negligence claim, the investigation may focus more heavily on what precautions a reasonable owner should have taken under the circumstances.

Woman holding back a leashed dog as it lunges at a man with a stick during a dog training session in a field

Can Someone Other Than The Dog Owner Be Held Liable?

The dog’s owner is usually the first person whose responsibility must be evaluated, but ownership does not always end the inquiry.

Depending on where and how the attack happened, potentially responsible parties may include:

  • The dog’s owner. An owner may be liable based on knowledge of the dog’s dangerous tendencies, negligent conduct, or both.
  • A handler or caretaker. A dog walker, pet sitter, family member, or another person who had control of the dog may bear responsibility in some situations.
  • A landlord or property owner. A landlord may potentially be liable for an attack involving a tenant’s dog when the required elements are present. In a strict liability claim, that can include knowledge that the dog was on the property, actual or constructive knowledge of its vicious propensities, and sufficient control to have the dog removed or confined.
  • Another party whose conduct contributed to the attack. Some cases involve additional people or entities whose actions need to be investigated before responsibility can be determined.

Identifying every potentially responsible party also matters because compensation is often paid through insurance. Homeowners or renters insurance may provide coverage for a dog-related injury, depending on the policy and facts involved.

Dog Attacks Can Cause Serious and Lasting Injuries

A dog does not have to be especially large to cause significant harm. Teeth can tear skin and damage tissue, while the force of an attack can also knock a person to the ground or cause them to fall while attempting to get away.

Dog bite and attack injuries can include:

  • Deep puncture wounds and lacerations.
  • Facial injuries.
  • Scarring and disfigurement.
  • Nerve and tendon damage.
  • Broken bones.
  • Hand, arm, and leg injuries.
  • Injuries caused by falling during an attack.
  • Infections requiring additional treatment.
  • Psychological trauma and fear following the incident.

Children can face particularly serious consequences when bites involve the face, head, or neck. Visible scarring may require continued medical attention and can affect a child long after the wound itself has healed.

The full impact of an attack may not be apparent immediately. A claim should account not only for the emergency treatment received after the bite but also for future care, lasting limitations, scarring, and other consequences supported by the medical evidence.

What Types of Damages Can a Dog Bite Victim Recover?

Compensation in a Rochester dog bite claim depends on the injuries, financial losses, available insurance, and evidence establishing responsibility.

Recoverable damages may include:

  • Emergency medical treatment.
  • Hospital and surgical expenses.
  • Follow-up care and rehabilitation.
  • Future medical treatment.
  • Lost wages.
  • Reduced future earning capacity when an injury affects the victim’s ability to work.
  • Pain and suffering.
  • Scarring or disfigurement.
  • Emotional and psychological effects of the attack.
  • Other losses caused by the injury.

There is no standard settlement amount for a dog bite. Two people attacked under similar circumstances may experience very different injuries and long-term effects. Determining the value of a claim requires documenting what the attack has actually cost the injured person and how it may continue to affect their life.

Why Choose Finkelstein & Partners for Your Rochester Dog Bite Case?

After a dog attack, some of the most important information may be completely outside your reach. You may not know whether the dog has behaved aggressively before, whether anyone has previously complained about it, what the owner knew, or which insurance policy may cover your injuries. You may also still be receiving treatment and have no way to know yet whether you will fully recover or be left with permanent scarring, pain, or other complications.

Finkelstein & Partners has represented injured New Yorkers for more than 65 years and recovered more than $3 billion for clients in personal injury cases. That experience includes dog-related injury claims, such as a $415,000 settlement for a client whose spine was reinjured when an aggressive dog knocked him down.

When you work with our firm, we can investigate the issues you should not have to uncover on your own. We may:

  • Investigate the dog’s history, prior incidents, and what its owner knew about its behavior.
  • Gather witness accounts, available records, video footage, and other evidence showing how the attack occurred.
  • Determine who may be responsible and identify insurance coverage that may apply.
  • Document your medical treatment, lost income, scarring, future care, and other consequences of the attack.
  • Handle the insurance claim and pursue litigation when necessary to seek fair compensation.

We have the resources to investigate both sides of a dog bite claim: why the attack happened and what it has cost you. Our goal is to build a case that reflects the full impact of your injuries while allowing you to focus on treatment and recovery. We handle qualifying personal injury cases on a contingency-fee basis, so there is no attorney fee unless we recover compensation for you.

What Should You Do After a Dog Bite in Rochester?

The steps taken after an attack can protect both your health and important evidence.

  1. Get medical care. Dog bites can cause deep wounds, tissue damage, and infection risks even when the injury initially appears manageable. Medical records also document when and how you were treated.
  2. Identify the dog and its owner. Obtain the owner’s name and contact information when possible. Information about the dog and its vaccination history may also become important.
  3. Photograph your injuries and where the attack happened. Take photographs as soon as you safely can and continue documenting bruising, wounds, stitches, scarring, or other visible changes as you heal.
  4. Get witness information. A person who saw the attack or was familiar with the dog beforehand may have information that later becomes important.
  5. Report the bite. Report the injury to the Monroe County Rabies Program at 585-753-5171. The county investigates reported animal contacts and oversees confinement or quarantine requirements when appropriate.
  6. Preserve anything related to the incident. Keep medical paperwork, photographs, communications with the owner, damaged clothing, and any insurance correspondence.
  7. Be cautious when discussing the claim with an insurance company. An insurer may ask for a statement or seek information before you know the full extent of your injuries. You do not need to guess about your prognosis or minimize symptoms that are still being evaluated.
  8. Talk to a dog bite lawyer in Rochester. An attorney can investigate the dog’s history, determine which liability rules may apply, identify available insurance coverage, and begin preserving evidence that could become harder to obtain over time. Getting legal advice early can also help you avoid mistakes when dealing with an insurance company.

Frequently Asked Questions About Rochester Dog Bite Claims

Yes. Rochester generally requires dogs to be restrained by a leash when they are off their owner’s property, with limited exceptions. Dogs in city parks must also generally be leashed unless they are within an authorized fenced area. If an attack involved an unleashed dog, that fact may be relevant when evaluating whether the owner used reasonable care.
If you were attacked while performing your job, such as while delivering mail, packages, food, or providing a service at someone’s home, you may have more than one avenue for recovering compensation. A work-related injury may qualify for workers’ compensation benefits, while a separate claim may also be available against a dog owner or another third party responsible for the attack. New York allows an injured employee to receive workers’ compensation benefits and pursue a third-party action in appropriate cases.
Yes. A parent or guardian can pursue an injury claim on behalf of a child who has been bitten or attacked by a dog. Children’s cases can require additional considerations, particularly when an injury causes facial scarring, requires future treatment, or may have lasting effects. Any settlement of a minor’s personal injury claim is also subject to court approval in New York.
No. A dog bite claim does not require proof that the owner intended for the dog to hurt you. Depending on the facts, liability may be based on the owner’s knowledge of the dog’s dangerous tendencies or on a failure to use reasonable care to prevent the injury.
The absence of insurance does not necessarily mean that you have no claim, but it can affect how compensation may be recovered. Homeowners and renters policies commonly include personal liability coverage that may apply when a pet injures someone, although individual policies can contain exclusions or other limitations. An attorney can investigate the available coverage and determine whether there are other potential sources of recovery.

Contact a Rochester Dog Bite Lawyer Today

andrew finkelstein
Personal Injury Attorney, Andrew Finkelstein

The days and weeks after a dog attack can matter. Evidence about the dog’s prior behavior may need to be uncovered, witnesses may need to be contacted, and the full extent of your injuries may take time to understand.

You do not have to sort through those issues while you are trying to recover. Finkelstein & Partners can evaluate what happened, explain your options under New York law, and pursue the compensation your injuries warrant. If you or someone in your family was hurt in a dog attack, contact us today for a free consultation with a Rochester dog bite lawyer.

Finkelstein & Partners’ Rochester Law Office


The Finkelstein & Partners Rochester Personal Injury law firm is located at 104A Metro Park #8 Rochester, NY 14623.

You can call us at 585-639-3534 for a free case evaluation.

Contact