James W. Shuttleworth headshot

James W. Shuttleworth

Partner | Personal Injury | Appellate | Bankruptcy | Veterans Disability

Areas of Practice

  • Personal Injury
  • Premises Liability & Construction Injuries
  • Products Liability
  • Appellate
  • Bankruptcy
  • Veterans Disability

Education

  • Pace University, B.B.A.
  • Pace Law School, J.D.

Admissions

  • New York
  • United States District Court, Northern, Southern, and Eastern Districts of New York
  • United States Bankruptcy Court, Northern, Southern, and Eastern Districts of New York

About James

James W. Shuttleworth has spent more than three decades securing justice and fair compensation for people hurt by others’ carelessness. A partner in Finkelstein & Partners’ Newburgh office, James joined the firm in 1993 and has been active in every phase of litigation since. He is known for his work on complex motions and appeals, the stages of a case where legal arguments can make or break a client’s recovery.

James chose personal injury law because he finds real satisfaction in holding negligent parties accountable and helping injured people recover what they’ve lost. That commitment has guided his work throughout his career.

James’s Role at Finkelstein & Partners

James focuses on complex motion and appellate practice, helping cases overcome the legal challenges defendants raise before trial and on appeal. He also plays a key role in the firm’s efforts to protect accident victims’ recoveries from insurance liens, so more of a settlement or award goes to the injured person.

James shares that knowledge with other legal professionals as well. He teaches continuing legal education classes on liens and their effect on personal injury cases, basic motion practice, and premises liability. He has taught for the firm’s CLE program and for Marist College’s Business Law and Legal Nurse programs.

Personal Injury Cases

James handles a wide range of personal injury cases, including:

  • Slip and fall accidents
  • Auto accidents
  • Premises liability cases
  • Construction injuries
  • Animal attacks
  • School injury cases
  • Products liability claims

What Clients Can Expect

James takes a client-centered approach. He involves clients throughout the process, explaining what’s happening and why, what to expect, and the risks and benefits of each available course of action. Clients can count on his full attention and timely, thorough communication.

He knows that motions and appeals can be especially hard for clients to follow, since it’s often unclear how the law and prior court decisions affect the chances of success. James makes a point of helping clients understand where their case stands and works with them to craft arguments aimed at a favorable outcome.

Case Stories

Over the years, James has resolved many cases favorably after successful motion practice across all areas of personal injury law. A few stand out:

Defeating Summary Judgment for an Injured Student

James defeated the defense’s motion for summary judgment in a case involving a young girl injured in gym class, which led to a substantial settlement for his client.

Overcoming a Serious Injury Challenge

In an auto accident case, the defense argued that James’s client hadn’t met New York’s serious injury threshold. James successfully resolved the case in his client’s favor.

A Complicated Toxic Gas Exposure Case

James handled a case involving exposure to toxic gas that required a highly technical and detailed analysis to resolve.

An Unusual Animal Attack

James’s case history even includes a donkey attack – proof that negligence can take unexpected forms.

He has also handled cases with unusual bankruptcy implications, drawing on his admission to practice in federal bankruptcy courts.

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Outside the Office

When he’s not at the office, James enjoys spending time with his family, going to the gym, and restoring old motorcycles.